Kalligas then moves to Plotinus' Enneads, providing a brief synopsis of each treatise and comments on passages of the kind I have mentioned above.
P-Pi ndpr@nd.edu, The Enneads of Plotinus: A Commentary, Volume 1. On the Presence of Being, One and the Same, Everywhere as a Whole (2), 7. The volume also includes the text of and notes on Plotinuss complementary statements in On Intelligible Beauty (Ennead 5.8.12). The volume ends with specific bibliographies for each particular treatise. 30425) have not been taken into account, although they are of major importance at least in the case of two passages from Enn. Plotinus on Beauty (Enneads 1.6 and 5.8-12): The Greek Text with Notes, quot;-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">, As a matter of policy, we do not share your information with anybody, and we will not send The English translation of Kalligas' Modern Greek is clear and elegant. The volume ends with the text of and notes on Plotinuss complementary statements in On Intelligible Beauty (Ennead 5.8.12). , Print length I would only point out that opposing intellectual exercise to experiential encounter (p. 52) is not felicitous, since for Plotinus the intellectual or noetic is highly experiential, having little to do with what we today associate with abstract thought and intellectualism.
: Throughout her commentary on grammatical problems, Wear shows sensitivity towards the problems which are likely to occur to intermediate students translating Plotinus or ancient Greek texts in general, i.e. We ask that comments be substantive in content and civil in tone and those that do not adhere to these guidelines will not be published. 1.6 and 5.8 is that Smith tries to pass between the Scylla and Charybdis of Plotinus interpretation of Platos aesthetics. both to identify users and fulfill orders. Although modern scholars have advocated getting away from the artificiality of Porphyry's arrangement and a return to the chronological order, Kalligas stays with the enneadic ordering (I feel that he is too kind to Porphyry here).
The notes are not overloaded with references to the other ancient sources or to the secondary literature (which is a good thing) but, usually, significant allusions to Plato, Aristotle or the Stoics are explained as well as the most important scholarly studies referred to. Or, perhaps, every point in it is a doorway! Kalligas also provides on occasion a fine-grained analysis of the structure of Plotinus' arguments, when this structure is difficult to grasp.[1]. 3 volumes. 1.6 and on the relationship between physical and noetic beauty (which he also already discussed in the previous book). More recently, cf. Read instantly on your browser with Kindle Cloud Reader.
The reader will find concise summaries after each step through the levels of reality and some useful, clearly arranged tables.
The treatises included by Porphyry, on thematic grounds (subjects having to do with ethics and natural philosophy), in Enneads I-III discuss, among other things: the human 'self', the virtues, happiness, beauty, evil, suicide, the stars, matter, the Gnostic view of the constitution of the world, fate, providence, love, eternity and time, and how nature produces. The first volume contained the first three Enneads (I, II, III), the second volume has the Fourth (IV) and the Fifth (V) Enneads, and the last volume was devoted to the remaining Ennead. For Fourth Ennead (IV), treatise number seven (7), chapter two (2), lines one to five (1-5), we write: E.g. Learn how to enable JavaScript on your browser. This is one of the tasks Kalligas undertakes in his comments on difficult or obscure passages in the Enneads. 2.12.7), thanks to inconsistencies of his syntax, linguistic idiosyncrasies and other peculiarities (like omission of in potential constructions or the usage of instead of ). Oxford: Clarendon Press, 19641984; referred to as the H-S2 or editio minor text) there is an academic convention of citing the Enneads by first mentioning the number of Ennead (usually in Romans from I to VI), the number of treatise within each Ennead (in arabics from 1 to 9), the number of chapter (in arabics also), and the line(s) in one of the mentioned editions.
The commentary on philosophical issues provides useful references, primarily to the main sources of Plotinus texts (Plato, Aristotle), but also to further important pre- and post-Plotinian works and parallel passages in the Enneads. The commentary covers grammatical and philosophical issues, but focuses justifiably on grammatical problems. anon.
ennea) or Enneads. , Enhanced typesetting T-Z, Sign in|Recent Site Activity|Report Abuse|Print Page|Powered By Google Sites, Bibliotheca Augustana (ed. : Plotinus composed the widely influential Neoplatonic work On Beauty (Ennead 1.6) in the third century CE. In the English-speaking world, Plotinus has suffered from his being enlisted posthumously in the cause of the late antique pagan theology of Proclus, in the cause of a new Christian theology by Marsilio Ficino in the Renaissance and in the cause of Hegelianism. The book under review is a reader for two of Plotinus most important and most famous treatises, Ennead I.6 and V.1. Sorry, there was a problem loading this page. The Introduction is shorter than in the one in Smiths earlier translation of Enn. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness. Enabling JavaScript in your browser will allow you to experience all the features of our site. Please report broken links. In the remark on (I.6.5.15) the substantive is unintentionally referred to as adjective (p. 48), while the misleading remark on (V.1.3.14)"(<)" instead of (<)seems to be misspelled (p. 133). 3rd Ennead Given his limited knowledge of Greek, it is usually assumed that he read Plotinus in Latin, using Marius Victorinus translation. However, we do retain personal information, : Apart from the more linguistic side of the commentary, what deserves to be highly praised is the philosophical elucidation of Plotinus argument and Smiths appreciation for the practical side of his works, namely the spiritual exercises and personal transformation to which both of the treatises he comments on exhort the reader. (c) 20072020 III, 5 [50], 9, 8 since III.5 was the fiftieth written by Plotinus. [4] P. Henry, Plotin et lOccident (Louvain, 1934). I.1 [53] - "What is the Living Being and What is Man? , File size I.6.3.28 (p. 36) was, I guess, supposed to say : with the participle has a causal force (not: conditional force), for the author rightly translates since. The philosophical context is, of course, limited in comparison to the previous commentary, but Smith explains in detail the intricacies of Plotinus syntax and often suggests illuminating readings of difficult places. Plato
Plotinus takes each principle to possess a primary activity of its essence (energeia ts ousias) and to produce an image (eidlon, eikn) deprived of power and being as its secondary activity (energeia ek ts ousias). Since Wears book is labelled Plotinus on Beauty and Reality, the reader might be disappointed not to find a separate introductory chapter which deals with the topic of beauty. Lucian Smith quite often quotes sections of a late treatise Enn. All in all, Andrew Smiths work is an excellent book for classicists and the historians of ancient philosophy interested in studying Plotinus fascinating and influential views on beauty, art and the contemplative ascent to the One.
Porphyry's edition does not follow the chronological order in which Enneads were written (see Chronological Listing below), but responds to a plan of study which leads the learner from subjects related to his own affairs to subjects concerning the uttermost principles of the universe. It is somehow surprising what Smith writes about Augustine and Plotinus, namely that it still remains unclear whether Augustine had direct access to the Enneads either in Greek or in a Latin translation (pp. It is also interesting that, in his entry on Plotinus in the Augustinus-Lexikon,[7] Smith is much more nuanced about this issue. The text is slightly revised (p. xlv); in the case of the hotly debated passages V.1.6.18 and V.1.7.6, for example, Wear sides convincingly with the editors who argue against the reflexive from H-S2 and prefer .
Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date. Porphyry edited the writings of Plotinus in fifty-four treatises, which vary greatly in length and number of chapters, mostly because he split original texts and joined others together to match this very number. Copyright 1995-2022 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. 1.6 and 5.8. The main part of the book is followed by a third section consisting of five appendices.
It is divided into short sections, the first of which is a brief sketch of Plotinus life. IV.5 [29] - "On Problems of the Soul (3) [Also known as, "On Sight"]. On the whole, the Introduction is a very accessible and interesting prelude to the detailed commentary on the selected texts.
Beside the Greek text and Wears commentary the reader will find a good deal of introductory and additional material in this volume. : Kalligas takes here, as his point of reference, the English translation by A. H. Armstrong (Plotinus, 1966-1988) and provides a list of his suggested improvements of the Greek text for Enneads I-III (657-668). He also does not claim that Plotinus was unaware of the differences between his own and his masters views. : [7] Plotinus, Augustinus-Lexikon, vol. The present publication collects, in one volume, in English translation, the synopses and notes for Enneads I-III, and we can look forward to two future volumes, covering Enneads IV-V and Ennead VI. 1996-2022, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we dont use a simple average. He also provides, with his critical edition, a Modern Greek translation of Plotinus' text, brief synopses of each Plotinian treatise, and detailed notes (philological, historical and philosophical) on difficult passages in the treatises. Prickard, 1918, adapted), Peith's Web (tr.
3.5 (On Love) and of Enn.
you marketing emails unless you give us consent. But the reader who is not might wonder why he adds two chapters of another treatise to the treatise On Beauty, especially since Enn. 1.6 and Enn. 2.2.5). 4.8.1.27-8). On the Origin and Order of the Post-Primary Beings, 3. How That Which is After the First Comes from the First, and on The One, 5. 4th Ennead A point that can be made also with regard to his earlier commentaries on Enn. Some inaccuracies can be detected in Appendices 4 and 5. 1230) is the main part of the book, where Wear presents the text of Ennead I.6 (pp. 1. For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now. The movement of thought in each treatise, another important feature of Plotinus' writing that is sometimes difficult to grasp, is somewhat lost in an approach concentrating on selected passages. Expressions of thanks or praise should be sent directly to the reviewer, using the email address in the review.
all in one large file]. The text with commentary is clearly divided into chapters and every chapter is preceded by a short synopsis. 197) and V.1 (pp.
The older approach to Plotinus, expressed by such eminent scholars as e.g. [8] The hypothesis was revived in an excellent book by Brian Dobell, Augustines Intellectual Conversion: The Journey from Platonism to Christianity (Cambridge, 2009). [2] Plotinus, Smith argues, was convinced that Plato had a coherent view of beauty and art, which is an approach not only interpretatively valid, but faithful to Plotinus self-understanding as a disciple and an exegete of Plato albeit not a blind, uncritical follower.
I.7.1.19, 20 and V.3.13.2, 3 for the Ones transcendence above intellection). On the Knowing Hypostases and That Which is Beyond, 4. Writing Passion: A Catullus Reader, Second Edition, Plotinus on Beauty and Reality: A Reader for Enneads I.6 and V.1 Teacher's Guide, A Tacitus Reader: Selections from Annales, Historiae, Germania, Agricola, and Dialogus, Latin for the New Millennium: Student Workbook, Level 1, 1st Ed, Caesar: Selections from his Commentarii De Bello Gallico, Writing Passion Plus: A Catullus Reader Supplement - Poems 6, 16, 32 and 57, Vergil's Aeneid: Selected Readings from Books 1, 2, 4, and 6. 1-2) : T - eBay Money Back Guarantee - opens in a new window or tab, Plotinus on Beauty (Enneads 1.6 and 5.8.1-2): The Greek Text with Notes by Smith, - for PayPal Credit, opens in a new window or tab, Learn more about earning points with eBay Mastercard, - eBay Return policy - opens in a new tab or window, - eBay Money Back Guarantee - opens in a new tab or window.
Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. On Whether Happiness (Well Being) Increases with Time, 7. Be the first to submit a review on this product! In this volume Andrew Smith first introduces readers to the Greek of Plotinus and to his philosophy in general, then provides the Greek text of and English notes on Plotinuss systematic argument and engaging exhortation to foster the inner self. Give as a gift or purchase for a team or group. 1st Ennead email
C. Mayer (Basel, 2016), 772-4.
2nd Ennead
We also welcome your feedback if you would like to tell us more. Although Plotinus' primary terms of reference are known to us (the works of Plato and of Aristotle), he also presupposes intermediary sources, commentators on Plato and Aristotle and other sources of the Hellenistic and early Roman imperial period, whom Plotinus does not name and whose works are in large part no longer available to us. [1] The crucial difference is that here we have the Greek text without translation (I was not able to find any information concerning the source of the Greek textis it the Henry-Schwyzereditio minor?) Seller assumes all responsibility for this listing. Next we have a section devoted to Plotinus as a Platonist, a member of the continuous philosophical tradition, claiming, famously, not to be an original thinker (leaving aside the question how he would put that in Greek) but an exegete of the divine Plato. The Preller-Ritter Extracts Forming a Conspectus Page; html or text), Richard Dufour's Plotinos bibliography (continuation of his, Plotinos Bibliography, Centre national de la recherche scientifique, Mad Cybrarian's Library (tr.
A-An 5.8 is not justified or commented upon in any way. : Thus the reader of this book can use it conveniently, perhaps in conjunction with study of Plotinus' works in the Greek of the Henry-Schwyzer edition (but Kalligas does not presuppose knowledge of Greek), while reading Armstrong's English translation. I.6. e.g. 1.6. The target readership of Sarah Klitenic Wears book are "students of Classics, philosophy, and theology with a year of introductory Greek grammar under their belt" (p. ix), for whom Wear wants to make Plotinus work accessible in his own language.
These ebooks can only be redeemed by recipients in the India. They concern the meaning of some words (even if, according to the information on p. 287, words in the word list "are defined as they occur in situ") and minor errors like wrong genitive forms and accents, e.g. The author of the Enneads was probably aware of the tensions or even discrepancies in Platos thought in this area, just, we might add, as he was aware of them with regard to the question of the relation between the soul and the body, when he discusses Platos views (we can even imagine a reverent, but noticeable, sigh when Plotinus says: What, then, does this philosopher say? We have, therefore, in the present publication, an invaluable companion to be used when reading the Plotinian treatises included in Enneads I-III. His volume then begins, as does Porphyry's edition, with Porphyry's Life of Plotinus.
(I give a selection): is given transitive force ('to put to death'); is rendered 'to go', which may hold for I.6.9.7 (without being completely adequate), but not for V.1.10.28 and other passages, where the verb is used transitively; the lemma gives only masculine and neuter endings of the adjective; incorrect genitive forms are , - and , -; examples for wrong or missing accents are , -, , -). Since the publishing of a modern critical edition of the Greek text by Paul Henry and Hans-Rudolf Schwyzer (Plotini Opera. More recent work, of the highest quality, on Plotinus has made it easier to come back to Plotinus himself and to his philosophy (to the work done by Henry, Schwyzer and Armstrong, we can add now the present volume by Kalligas), and it may be that the residual prejudice against him that can still be felt in particular in some Oxbridge/Ivy league philosophy departments (the late Michael Frede was an exception) may weaken. That the Intelligibles are not Outside the Intellect, and on The Good, 6. ", I.7 [54] - "On the Primal Good and Secondary Forms of Good [Otherwise, 'On Happiness']", I.8 [51] - "On the Nature and Source of Evil", II.3 [52] - "Whether the Stars are Causes", II.8 [35] - "On Sight or on how Distant Objects Appear Small", II.9 [33] - "Against Those That Affirm The Creator of the Kosmos and The Kosmos Itself to be Evil" [generally quoted as "Against the Gnostics"], III.4 [15] - "On our Allotted Guardian Spirit", III.6 [26] - "On the Impassivity of the Unembodied", III.8 [30] - "On Nature, Contemplation and the One", IV.1 [21] - "On the Essence of the Soul (1)", IV.2 [4] - "On the Essence of the Soul (2)", IV.3 [27] - "On Problems of the Soul (1)", IV.4 [28] - "On Problems of the Soul (2)".
