Unlike the liquid detergent, you cant adjust how much you put in based on the load's size, so you cant stretch out a single pack any longer than 61 washes. By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. The Simply line is available in liquid, and Tide Simply Odor Control and Tide Simply Plus Oxi are available in pods. Tide Simply is a budget-friendly option that costs less than Tide Original. Tide vs. Gain Laundry Detergent: Whats the Difference? The container had clear instructions for the quantity of detergent to use based on the size of your load of laundry, and since we already knew some pro tips, there wasnt much of a mess. Get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. Learn more. When it came time to pour the detergent into the washing machine, it didnt all come out, and a lot was stuck to the sides of the cup. We purchased the Tide Simply Clean and Fresh Liquid Laundry Detergentso our writer could put it to the test. The chart below makes it easy to compare the cost of Tide vs. The reviewers praised Tide Original, naming it the Best Single Dose Laundry Detergent, Best Powder Laundry Detergent, Best Deep Cleaning Laundry Detergent, and Best Liquid Laundry Detergent with Bleach Alternative. Tide Original is a top-selling detergent, but the one criticism is that its too expensive. It usually takes three or four separate products to get that result. The Tide Original formula has twice as many ingredients as Tide Simply. To test its stain removal, we put a small spoonful of marinara sauce on a baby shirt and, once it was dried and set in, we poured a little of the detergent directly on the stain before tossing it in with the rest of the load (with the full amount of detergent needed for its size). USA TODAY network website, Reviewed, covered the best laundry detergents, and listed Tide Original as one of the top picks. We think the detergent performed pretty well in this aspect. The detergent comes with a clear measuring cup with a little divot along the rim for ease of pouring the detergent without making a mess. Tide Simply only comes in liquid detergent and pods. Tide Simply. Are you shopping for laundry detergent but cant decide between Tide and Tide Simply? Tide vs. Kirkland: Which Laundry Detergent Is Better? We used this detergent in a few different loads of laundry. Tide: Which Laundry Detergent Is Better? We love the performance and smell. our process. Readers Digest reviewed the 17 Best Laundry Detergents and applauded several Tide Original products. Use the links below to navigate the comparison: If youre in a hurry, heres a quick, side-by-side comparison of Tide vs. Hes studied consumer buying behavior for 10+ years and has managed marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands. As its name suggests, Tide Simply is a simpler formula containing fewer ingredients than Tide Original. As an Amazon Associate, Prudent Reviews earns fees when you click on links within our articles and make qualifying purchases. When hes not testing the latest home products, hes spending time with his family, cooking, and doing house projects. Tide Original has nine fragrances, and Tide Simply features six. Overall, we think it did well. I called Procter & Gamble, the company that owns Tide. productslearn more about Tide vs. The information provided on this website is not intended to be a replacement or substitute for professional advice. Each large laundry load costs about $.29 to washnot bad for a scented high-performance detergent. Why? Her several years of experience has included contributions to Romper, Femestella.com, InspireMore, Moms.com, Introvert Dear, This Is My Brave, as well as various other publications. Tide Simply Clean and Fresh is a budget-friendly liquid laundry detergent that provides a good clean, pleasant smell, and leaves clothes feeling surprisingly soft. While the stain was mostly gone, there were still some remnants of it. 2022 Prudent Reviews LLC. For all the extra things you get in a pod, the additional $.04 might be worth it. It holds enough detergent for 89 large loads of laundry. When we pressed the button to dispense the detergent into the cup, everything went well, and there was no mess. Which Tide Detergent Is the Best? After testing Tide Simply Clean and Fresh liquid laundry detergent, we'd say its worth the buy. Effective on minor stains and everyday wear, Pods, liquid detergent, powder detergent, to-go wipes, to-go pen, laundry booster, washing machine cleaner, antibacterial spray, Original, Hygienic Clean Heavy Duty 10X, Hygienic Clean Heavy Duty 10X Free, Plus Febreze, Plus Downy, Free and Gentle, Oxi, Coldwater Clean, Bleach Alternative, Ultra Stain Release, Free and Sensitive, Clean and Fresh, Clean and Sensitive, Odor Rescue, With Bleach, With Oxi, Original, Mountain Spring, Clean Breeze, Spring Meadow, Lavender, Botanical Rain, Fresh Coral Blast, Febreze, Febreze Sport, Line Dry Fresh, Fresh Linen, Refreshing Breeze, Daybreak Fresh, Berry Blossom, Clean and Fresh, Cool Cotton, Sodium And MEA Salts Of C12-18 Fatty Acids, Diethylenetriamine, Methyl Di-T-Butyl Hydroxyhydrocinnamate, Polyoxyalkylene Substituted Chromophore (color), Tide Original Liquid Laundry Detergent (64 Loads), Tide Original Liquid Laundry Detergent (96 Loads), Tide Original Powder Laundry Detergent (102 Loads), Tide Original Laundry Detergent (32 Loads), Tide Simply Clean & Fresh Liquid Laundry Detergent (89 Loads), Tide Simply Free & Sensitive Liquid Laundry Detergent (89 Loads), Tide Simply +Oxi Liquid Laundry Detergent (74 Loads). In this comparison of Tide vs. Tide: Which Detergent and Stain Remover Is the Best? All of the clothes came out feeling pretty soft, smelling good, and relatively fluffy. Arm & Hammer: Which Laundry Detergent Is Better? It's a given; a good, dependable laundry detergent is essential in every household. Get daily tips and tricks for making your best home. Keep reading for our full product review. Overall, everything was pretty clean and easy to use. After everything was done and dry, we checked the spot on the little shirt. Both Tide Original and Tide Simply have a wide array of fragrances.

Another significant difference between Tide and Tide Simply is their cleaning power. In normal circumstances, we're probably a little high maintenance when it comes to laundry. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission. Connect with Andrew viaemail,LinkedIn, or thePrudent Reviews YouTube channel. I went straight to the source to get an expert opinion on the differences between Tide and Tide Simply. Simply put, the original Tide is tougher on stains and odors than Tide Simply. The reviewer tested the detergent with a marinara sauce stain, and while Tide Simply did clean the mark, there was evidence of the stain leftover. 11 Pros and Cons, What Products Contain Borax? However, since pods came out, we haven't looked back. If youre trying to save money and looking for a budget-friendly alternative, pick Tide Simply. It was ranked second of nine, with great cleaning power. The review says that Original is easy to find and widely trusted by consumers. Formulas vary in terms of strength and additional ingredients. Kitchen & CookingHome MaintenanceCleaningHome EssentialsBrowse All CategoriesBrowse All Brands, About UsMeet the TeamContact UsJobsTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy. Tide Simply, youll learn how these two detergents differ in cleaning power, ingredients, fragrances, price, and more. Tide Pods Coldwater Clean: This isnt the same formula as Simply Clean and Fresh; each pod has added stain remover, odor fighter, and a coldwater clean additive (whatever that is). Gain Blissful Breeze Laundry Detergent With Aroma Booster: The 3.54-liter bottle of this liquid detergent retails for around $12, so each load of laundry costs around $.15. Tide vs. Persil: Which Laundry Detergent Is Better? However, when we stopped pushing the button, it quickly releases to cut off the detergent's flow, so theres a little splash factor. Ashley has been writing for The Spruce since January 2020. (Top 8 Compared). Its a reliable detergent for everyday laundry but might not pack enough power for stubborn stains. By the end, youll have all the key facts to decide which detergent is best for your needs. The one con mentioned was that Tide Original is not ideal for people with sensitive skin. The reviewer gave Tide Simply high praise for leaving clothes soft, fluffy, and pleasant smelling. One thing to note is that the container can still leak a few drops of detergent, so if you dont have the cup over it to catch the drips, expect to find little sticky droplets beneath the container's spout. All vs. Tide Simply did not make the rankings. A total of four detergents made the list, including Tide Free & Gentle, Tide Plus Ultra Stain Release, Tide Plus Bleach Alternative, and Tide Hygienic Clean Heavy Duty 10X Power Pods. Tide Simply Clean and Fresh liquid laundry detergent promises to keep your washing cycles affordable without sacrificing performance and quality. Its available in liquid, powder, pods, and specialty items like wipes and pens. Once youve poured the detergent into the washing machine, you can put the measuring cup over the spout, and it will click in and stay there until the next load of laundry. The spot wasnt super obvious, but it was enough that someone could probably catch it in the right light if they werent looking for it. Tide: Which Laundry Detergent Is Better? Here are the options (note: these change often). We've updated our Privacy Policy, which will go in to effect on September 1, 2022. Fabric Scent and Texture: Surprisingly good, Competition:Saturated liquid laundry detergent market, The Best Laundry Detergents to Get out the Grime, Simply Clean and Fresh Liquid Laundry Detergent, The 11 Best Laundry Detergent Pods Available, The Best Smelling Laundry Detergent to Keep Your Clothes Fresh, These Are the 10 Best Laundry Detergents for Sensitive Skin. Tide Original and Tide Simply vary drastically in the number of available products. We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best The most notable difference between Tide and Tide Simply is the ingredients. Lastly, she mentioned that Tide Simply is a more economical option if youre looking to save.

The Best Laundry Detergent: Liquid, Pods, or Powder? She said, Tide Simply is a thinner, less concentrated formula thats the biggest difference. She further explained by saying, Tide and Tide Simply both work great for normal laundry, but if youre a mechanic or work in construction, Tide Simply may not penetrate those stains., She also confirmed that Tide Simply has fewer ingredients, which is why its thinner and less powerful. Although it is a more expensive brand, people trust the Tide name and are willing to pay the difference. Tide Original offers specialized products, such as the to-go pen. How are they different? They also mentioned that Tide Simply is an affordable laundry detergent for large families. The chart below lists the ingredients for Tide Original liquid laundry detergent and Tide Simply Clean & Fresh liquid laundry detergent. If youre looking for a detergent with similar performance and an even lower price tag, this is a good option. Its affordable, performs well, and leaves your clothes feeling fresh, soft, and clean. I also reveal what Procter & Gamble, the company that owns Tide, says about both options. Lets look at how Tide Original compares to Tide Simply in terms of performance, according to independent tests. Because Tide Original is a thicker, more concentrated detergent containing more cleaning enzymes. Tide Original is available in ten formulas, including: Tide Simply is available in six formulas, including: Only Tide Original provides special formulas for heavy-duty messes and cold water wash cycles. Its a great option for a family that does a lot of laundry. Nothing in the Simply line comes in powder form. This Consumer Reports study didnt have great things to say about Tide Simplys cleaning performance. We may earn a fee if you buy via links in this post (at no extra cost to you). When we tested this detergent, we didnt use any extra products and were pleased with the results. When I spoke to the product specialist, I asked one simple question: whats the difference between Tide and Tide Simply? Procter & Gamble launched Tide Simply to appeal to budget-conscious shoppers. Purex vs. Tide Original is more expensive than Tide Simply because its a more robust formula with extra stain-fighting enzymes. OxiClean vs. The container is too heavy to pour the detergent, so it is designed to sit on a shelf on its side and dispenses the detergent through a little spout. To view the ingredients of any Tide product, go to Tide.com, navigate to the product, and click on the SmartLabel link. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Tide Simply contains fewer enzymes, odor removers, process aids, and sud reducers. Tide Simply was not mentioned in the review. This detergent retails for around $25 for the 4-liter size. The remaining stain was not obvious but still showed in certain lighting. Learn more about both options on Tide.com and Amazon at the links below: Andrew is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Prudent Reviews. All of the clothes came out feeling pretty soft, smelling good, and relatively fluffy. Join our free newsletter and get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. Tide Original is more effective on tougher stains, while Tide Simply is better for everyday washing. All content on PrudentReviews.com is intended for informational purposes only. Prices vary by product and form (liquid, pods, specialty formulas, etc.). However, experts at The Spruce gave Tide Simply a Very Good rating.

Under normal circumstances, our household is Tide all the way. Which version of Tide is better? So, we were happy to try out this detergent. Another key difference between Tide Simply and Tide Original is the formula variety. Tide Simply. Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: What Procter & Gamble Says About Tide vs. When we noticed this was a liquid detergent, we didn't relish the thought. Both offer formulas for sensitive skin. It said Tide Simply is no match for common stains. They do not recommend Tide Simply, saying, [You can] find much better options.. If you dont mind paying more for extra cleaning power, go with Tide Original. The Original line offers a wider variety of products. These are the current prices on Amazon (click the price to learn more about each product). A pack of 61 pods retails for around $20, which comes out to around $.33 per load. She said, Tide Simply doesnt have as many cleaning enzymes as the original Tide.. Read our review to learn whether or not this detergent lives up to its promise. The formula is similar to Tide Simply Clean and Fresh but claims to have an aroma booster, which likely means it has a stronger scent than Tide. Handles strong stains like dirt, oil, grass, and blood, Thinner, less concentrated formula. We like everything to smell super fresh, feel soft, and be fluffy. We are a family of four, and while the economy size liquid detergent is easier on the budget, the pods are quicker to grab and don't leave a drippy mess behind. Is Fabric Softener Necessary? Tide Simply. There are ten formulas available in Tide Original and six types of Tide Simply. 39 Examples and Alternatives, Over 25 ingredients (contains more cleaning enzymes), Thicker, more concentrated formula. The main thing it lacks is the stain remover, but there are separate products you can purchase to fill in that gap. All Rights Reserved. Good Housekeeping put several detergent brands to the test against 20 different stains like oil, coffee, and wine. Having grown up using this kind of detergent, we knew that you could toss the cap in with the clothes, and itll come out squeaky clean, so we did that to avoid a mess. Bottom Line: Should You Choose Tide or Tide Simply? They highlighted its superior stain-removing ability. So, we felt like the clothes were clean, but the detergent fell flat with stains.

We'd probably still use some scent boosters and dryer sheets with it to get the results we prefer. Its not huge, but we hate the mess of sticky liquid detergent, so we were mindful of cleaning it up right away. Before I give my recommendation, lets quickly recap the differences: Bottom line Tide Original costs more, but its a stronger, more concentrated formula with additional stain-fighting enzymes. The Best Fabric Softeners for Fluffy Towels, Sheets, and Clothes, The Best Green Laundry Detergents to Clean With Care, All Free Clear Liquid Laundry Detergent Review, The Best Baby Laundry Detergents for Your Little One, The Best Laundry Detergents for Septic Systems and a Safer Routine, The Best Laundry Whiteners to Keep Your Clothes Bright, The Best Laundry Detergents to Remove Odors From Clothes, Tide Brights + Whites Rescue Pacs Make Whitening Easier, How to Use HE Laundry Detergent Correctly. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Both offer a wide variety of scents. But which one is right for you? The 4-liter container of Tide Simply Clean and Fresh is huge. Tide and Tide Simply are both reliable detergents from one of the most trusted brands in the business. In fact, Tide Simply has about half as many ingredients.